If your Google Ads account shows an optimization score of 98%, there is a decent chance you are paying for it. Either someone clicked "Apply all" on a stack of suggestions, or auto-apply did it for you while you were running your business. The score looks like a report card. It is actually a sales funnel, and the person on the other end of it is Google.

I run a digital marketing agency, and the first thing I check when a small business hands me an account they are unhappy with is not the keywords or the ads. It is the auto-apply settings. I'll tell you what I look for, which recommendations are worth accepting, and the questions to put to whoever manages your account.

What does Google Ads auto-apply actually change in my account?

Auto-apply lets Google implement certain recommendations on its own, without asking you first. Depending on what is switched on, that can include adding new keywords, expanding match types, creating or removing ad assets, and adjusting bidding or targeting settings. You find the controls under the Recommendations section of your account, where auto-apply is listed with a toggle per category.

The key detail is that these changes happen inside live campaigns that are spending your money. Nobody reviews them first. If Google adds a broad match version of your best keyword, your budget starts flowing to searches you never approved, and you find out when the invoice or the lead quality tells you.

Picture a plumber spending $2,000 a month at about $60 a lead. If a loosened match type sends even 25% of that budget to irrelevant searches such as "plumber jobs" or "DIY pipe repair," that is $500 a month, or $6,000 a year, buying clicks that never turn into a phone call. This is an illustration, not a client number, but the arithmetic is the point: small-budget accounts have no room for experiments they did not choose.

Why does Google push the optimization score so hard?

Because the score measures how many of Google's suggestions you have accepted, not how profitable your campaigns are. Many recommendations lean toward higher budgets, broader targeting, and more automation, all of which tend to increase spend. That does not make every suggestion bad. It means the incentive behind the list is not the same as yours.

Your goal is cost per lead or cost per sale that works for your margins. A campaign can sit at 60% optimization score and be highly profitable. Another can sit at 100% and bleed money. I have never once seen a client's revenue track their score, so I tell them to ignore it as a target. Treat it as a to-do list that Google wrote, which you read critically.

Which recommendations are safe to accept, and which should I ignore?

I sort them into three buckets. Here is how I handle each.

Usually fine to accept after a look: fixing broken ads or disapproved assets, adding sitelinks, callouts, and call extensions that match services you actually offer, and fixing missing conversion tracking. These improve what the ad shows or what you can measure, and they rarely move your spend.

Accept only with a reason and a watch period: new responsive search ad variations, and bidding strategy changes. If you do accept a bidding change, make it yourself on a date you write down, so you can compare cost per lead for the following 14 days against the 14 days before.

Ignore by default for small accounts: raising your budget, switching to broad match keywords, expanding to search partner or display networks, and "improve your targeting" suggestions. A budget increase recommendation in particular should only be accepted if your campaign is limited by budget while your cost per lead is already beating your target. If it is not both, the recommendation is just asking for more money.

How do I turn auto-apply off?

Open your account, go to Recommendations, and look for the Auto-apply option, usually near the top of the page. Review each category and switch off anything you did not deliberately choose. Google changes its menus now and then, so if the layout looks different, search the Google Ads help center for "manage auto-apply recommendations" and follow the current steps.

Then write down what was on before you changed it. If your results shift in the next two to four weeks, you want to know whether it was the old setting or something else. Do this on a day when you are not also changing ads or budgets, or you will not be able to tell what caused what.

What should I ask my agency or freelancer about this?

This is the part I would bookmark. Ask these five questions, and treat a vague answer to any of them as a warning sign:

  • Is auto-apply on or off in my account right now, and who decided that?
  • Which recommendations have you accepted in the last 90 days, and what happened to cost per lead afterward?
  • Do you report on optimization score? (If it is their headline metric, they are grading themselves on Google's homework.)
  • Who is notified when a recommendation changes a bid, budget, or match type?
  • Do I own the account, with admin access, so I can see the change history myself?

That last point matters more than it sounds. The Change History tab in Google Ads shows who changed what and when, including changes Google made on its own. If you cannot see it, you cannot audit it. When we take over an account at Sun BPO, auto-apply is the first setting I check, and the change history is the second thing I read, before I touch a single keyword.

Be fair to agencies, too. A good manager sometimes accepts recommendations on purpose, because some of them are correct. The difference is that they chose it, tested it, and can tell you what it did. Auto-apply removes that choice.

The bottom line: for most small businesses spending under $5,000 a month, turn auto-apply off, review recommendations yourself once a month, and judge your account on cost per lead and booked jobs, not on a score out of 100. If your agency cannot explain what it has accepted and why, that is a bigger problem than any setting.

Ramesh M is the founder of Sun BPO Solutions and has managed paid search campaigns for small and mid-sized businesses since 2015. He leads the editorial team at Signal Daily News.

FAQ

It depends on the account and how it was created. Some accounts, especially ones set up through simplified or guided flows, have certain auto-apply categories enabled without the owner realizing it. The only reliable check is to open the Recommendations section and review the auto-apply settings yourself.

For most small businesses spending under $5,000 a month, yes. You can still review and accept individual recommendations manually. The goal is not to reject everything Google suggests, but to make sure every change to a live, spending campaign is one you chose and can measure.

No. The optimization score is an estimate of how many available recommendations you have applied. Google does not use it to rank your ads or set your costs. A profitable account with a middling score is better than an unprofitable account with a perfect one.

Open the Change History tool in Google Ads. It lists changes with dates and the user or system that made them, including automated changes. Check it monthly, and ask your agency to walk you through anything you do not recognize.

It is a yellow flag, not automatically a red one. If it is the main metric in their report, be cautious, because it measures acceptance of Google's suggestions rather than business results. Ask them to lead with cost per lead, conversion volume, and revenue or booked jobs.

Record your current settings and the last 30 days of cost per lead, switch off the auto-apply categories you did not choose, and review Change History for broad match or budget changes you did not approve. Then give it two to four weeks before drawing conclusions, and avoid changing other settings at the same time.